Buylist Guide

Everything you need to turn your collection into cash or store credit at our store.

1. Build your cart

Pick a game, search or filter to your cards, choose the condition and finish, set quantities, and add them to your cart. Your cart follows you across every game — sell Magic and Pokémon in the same order.

2. Cash or credit

Toggle between Cash and Store Credit at any time. Store credit is applied to your account instantly on approval.

3. Ship your cards

After checkout we email a packing slip and instructions. Pack safely (see below), include the slip, and send them our way.

4. Get paid

Our team verifies and grades every card on arrival. We confirm the final offer, then pay out by your chosen method. Track status any time with your order ID.